Keira Knightley is the perfect Anna to my mind: almost impossibly, effortlessly beautiful and charming. I mean, seriously, just look:
Knightley is an amazing actor, able to convey great emotion with great naturalness, so I had no concerns there. More worrisome to me, after viewing the first trailers, was the casting of Vronsky. Aaron Taylor-Johnson did not appear to be the charismatic powerhouse I was expecting; he looked more like a callow youth, a lightweight. But he was an admirable Vronsky: he had chemistry with Knightley and a sneaky gravitas underneath that blond mop.
The surprise of the bunch, though, was Matthew Macfadyen as Oblonsky. It took me a good twenty minutes to figure out why he looked so familiar, and wow—what a performance. Macfadyen usually plays characters who are quiet or intense, so his bonhomie and comic turn were a revelation. I left thinking that Macfadyen could be the British Tom Hanks, a kind of Everyman in looks, able to play any type of character.
The most amazing aspect of the film is Joe Wright's direction. Anna Karenina is the great novel of realism, and yet Wright eschews realism completely in his adaptation. The entire film is presented as a series of tableaus or little plays presented on a stage. There will be a party on a stage, and characters will leave via catwalks that represent street life, with vendors and passersby populating the rafters. A toy train set will stand in for the train that takes Anna to Moscow on that first fateful trip. Even outdoor scenes like the horse race are presented as dramatic spectacles, with the horses running across the stage and onlookers watching from the balcony:
Set designs (holla to production designer Susan Greenwood) are self-consciously stagey and artificial, like this one of the train station:
Or this shot of Anna toward the end of the movie, which has become more melodramatic and operatic in style:
The cinematography is super rich and, well, cinematic, not naturalistic but uber aesthetic. Take a look at this amazeballs shot of Vronsky at the train station. If you maximize the image you can see how utterly gorgeous and stylized the shot is:
The only break in the artifice comes when Levin is in the countryside, which represents a more authentic way of life for Tolstoy:
One of my favorite scenes was the ball scene in which Vronsky and Anna first appear together in public and Kitty recognizes that Vronsky has lost interest in her. The attendees engage in an utterly fake form of ballroom dancing but one that serves the story brilliantly. The dancers' hands weave back and forth, signaling entanglement for Anna and Vronsky. For Kitty, foisted off on old men and straining desperately to catch sight of Vronsky, those weaving arms are a cage that keep hemming her in, not allowing her to escape and reach out to Vronsky, to pull him back from Anna's orbit.
There are lots of other visual touches, like the way Anna is increasing pictured with a veil or railing shadows on her face, making her looked trapped or caged:
And one repeated image is that of the crenellation at the edge of the main stage, which frames the stage and marks off the dramatic space of representation. This image reoccurs in almost every location, from the train station to the bedroom, where it forms part of the footboard at the end of Anna and Karenin's bed. You can see it at the bottom of the first image in this blog entry, and I'll repeat it here in the theater poster:
Wright and the actors do a stupendous job of combining the stylized visuals with acting that is still realistic, surely not an easy thing to achieve. Joe Wright has always had a flair for dramatic shots, like this one from Atonement:
Or this one, whose artificiality in the set design is quite deliberate:
Fans of his adaptation of Pride & Prejudice will remember that amazing scene when the servants close up Netherfield, lofting white sheets in the air to drape over the furniture, as the camera backs farther and farther out of the room, onto the balcony, and finally outside the house altogether and the servants finally close the shutters, signalling the shutting down of Jane's hopes. The backing up of the camera through the window and out past the balcony created the same kind of framing that is so prevalent in his Anna Karenina.
It's encouraging to see Wright's outside-the-box adaptation alongside the Wachowskis' adaptation of Cloud Atlas. Maybe a new era of experimentation in relatively mainstream films is brewing.